Ueli Steck and the Burden of Proof

Ueli Steck – sometimes called “The Swiss Machine,” is a giant in the sport of alpinism.  I know this isn’t an alpinism blog, but when I first saw the movie about Ueli’s ascent of the North Face of the Eiger in Reel Rock 2010, I was captivated by the man and his accomplishments. 

Last October, Ueli summited Annapurna, a Himalayan peak over 8000 meters tall.  He did it by himself, lost his camera in an avalanche, and returned to his friends.  Other than his word, this is nothing to prove whether Ueli actually stood on the summit or not.  Two Sherpas came forward several months later to say they saw his headlamp approximately 200 feet below the summit sometime around midnight.  Controversy has swirled around the ascent, and Ueli’s receipt of a Piolet d’Or award last month have heightened attention on that controversy.


Annapurna, Nepal. Photo: wikipedia

The Piolet d’Or (Golden Ice Axe) are yearly awards recognizing accomplishments that exhibit “high technical level and commitment,” as well as “respect for the mountains…beauty of movement, and the spirit in which people climb these mountains.” They have been awarded since the early 1990s, and have always had a degree of skepticism packaged into them.  The jury of accomplished alpinists does not have strictly quantifiable criteria with which to judge, and alpinism itself is open to a great deal of interpretation.  Furthermore, in a sport where so much is done in pairs or solo, the integrity of the athletes is necessarily presumed.

After his ascent, Steck came under scrutiny due to the lack of evidence.  He has consistently stated that he lost his camera and a glove in an avalanche on the way up (in an area known for avalanches, this is unsurprising); further, he has asserted that the altimeter on his GPS was broken, so it was impossible for him to obtain proof.  His receipt of the Piolet d’Or made the issue even more important – if awards are handed out without proof, what is to prevent people from their own fabrications?

The loose standards for judging – and lack of a verification requirements – for the Piolets d’Or is an issue of its own.  But as a mediocre climber in a city not known for its mountains, the ethical issues are far more interesting to me.  Since I first saw his ascent of the Eiger in 2010, I have paid casual attention to his career, and have had nothing but respect and awe for the unassuming man and his accomplishments.  (Even after the incident on Everest last year, to which I’ll include only a Google search link rather than any of the dozen one-sided accounts.  They’re all interesting reads, and the actual truth of what happened is still unclear.) 

Ueli after receiving his Piolet d'Or. Photo: montagne.tv

Ueli after receiving his Piolet d’Or. Photo: montagne.tv

So what? Why do I care? I want to believe Ueli Steck can do what he’s claimed to do, because otherwise I have been wrong to give him that respect.  I want to believe in Ueli Steck’s integrity, because otherwise I must doubt everyone else I have believed in as pinnacles of their sport.

It is so easy for us to demand evidence of everything.  In this digital age, providing proof shouldn’t be a big ask.  But demanding proof goes against much of what I’ve found freeing about climbing.  The deeply personal nature of our sport – and of Ueli’s, and of many others – means that my accomplishments are, by necessity, my own.  My sends are my own, as are my failures.  I want to do it completely, and I want to do it right, and I believe anyone who is driven by the same desire to stand on top of mountains has the same ethics, the same standards. 

Only Ueli knows whether he summited Annapurna last October, but he says he did.  I’ve decided that for me, that’s enough – his reputation, and my own admiration (maybe too starry-eyed), is enough for me to trust him.  Absence of proof is not proof of failure; I will continue to trust in my heroes until I have a reason not to.  That’s part of what makes them heroes.


About Peak Experiences

Love rock climbing? Me too. Peak is a giant box of climbing and fun, located in Midlothian Virginia, and has been around since 1998. Stronger Than Yesterday is our online resource for all things climbing, in Richmond and out in the wider world.
This entry was posted in News and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Talk back!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s